Friday, September 04, 2026
You don't need a national ad budget to get cut-through — you need dominance in the community your customers already trust.
Last updated 21 November 2026. Published by Simple-Growth (Motherbase Limited). Market: New Zealand and the United States.
You've put off a decision about your biggest competitor for weeks: fight harder, cut your price, or do something else entirely. Getting it wrong feels expensive, so nothing happens. The quickest way to decide is not more research on that rival. It's one hour finding out what is actually squeezing your margin.
When a competitor gets close, the natural reaction is to study them harder and get ready for a price fight. But the rival you can see is only one of five things that decide how much profit you keep. The others are easy to miss: how quickly someone new could copy you, how much your suppliers can push up your costs, how much your biggest customers can push down your price, and whether customers could choose a cheaper alternative instead. You can beat the rival you're watching and still lose your margin to one of the other four.
These five questions come from Michael Porter, a Harvard Business School professor, who first set them out in Harvard Business Review in 1979. He called them the Five Forces. In plain words, each one asks: who has the power to take profit from you?
Kevin D'Ambros-Smith, a New Zealand business coach who has coached 200+ businesses one-on-one across 30+ industries, worked with a New Zealand forensics specialist that wanted to win work in the United States. The obvious plan was to compete head-on with established American firms that had bigger budgets and longer track records.
The five questions showed the real problem was not the rivals. It was the buyers. US law firms and insurers trusted the names they had used for years, and a newcomer could only win that trust by underpricing for a long time. So instead of fighting the leading American firm, the specialist partnered with it, and borrowed the trust buyers already had.
The point in one line: they stopped competing with the trusted firm and started working with it.
"I catch up with Kevin once a week and it is definitely the highlight of my week. He just sees different opportunities so clearly. I would not have considered the B2C market as an opportunity before working with Kevin and now it is a major focus for us. He has opened up so many new opportunities for us."
— John Roberts, Co-owner and COO, Oragene
Start with one number: where has your margin moved most in the last 12 months? That is usually where the real pressure sits. Then write one honest line for each of the five questions above, and circle the one that worries you most. That circled answer, not your loudest competitor, is where your next decision belongs.
In Kevin's coaching, owners can name their rivals in a minute but rarely write down the other four answers, because admitting a supplier or a big customer has the upper hand is uncomfortable. A second person, such as a coach, an adviser or a trusted peer, often spots that answer faster because they are not inside your business every day.
A set of five questions from Harvard professor Michael Porter that shows who has the power to take profit from a business: rivals, newcomers, suppliers, big customers and cheaper alternatives.
Look at where your margin has moved most in the last 12 months. That is usually where the pressure is coming from.
Block one hour this week, check your margin, and write one honest line for each of the five questions before you react to your next competitor's move.
More practical guides for owners are in the Simple-Growth growth tips hub. Last updated 21 November 2026.
Stuck on a competitor decision? Kevin helps owners find what is really squeezing their margin.