Sunday, September 06, 2026

Burst campaigns reset to zero every time. Here's why a sustainable weekly cadence beats an intense one-month push, and how to protect it through the slow months.

Every October, a version of the same scene plays out in boardrooms across New Zealand, Australia and the United States: an SME owner and their leadership team sit down to write next year's plan, and everyone in the room quietly assumes it will work. Most strategic plans do not fail because the thinking was lazy. They fail because nobody in the room was willing to say out loud which part of it would not hold up. If you want a growth strategy that survives contact with next year, the fix is not a longer planning day or a glossier template. It is a single 20-minute exercise you run before you finalise anything, built from a method Kevin has used with clients across more than 30 industries over 30-plus years in business.

The Optimism Nobody Will Challenge

The real enemy here is not a bad plan. It is planning optimism: the quiet social pressure that stops anyone in a strategy session from naming the specific way the plan could fail, because doing so feels disloyal to a room that has already agreed to be excited about it. Researchers have had a fix for this since 1989. Deborah Mitchell, J. Edward Russo and Nancy Pennington found that asking people to imagine an outcome had already happened, something they called prospective hindsight, improved people's ability to correctly identify the real reasons behind that outcome by around 30 percent compared with simply asking what might go wrong. Imagining failure as already real, rather than merely possible, unlocks specific and honest answers that a hypothetical question never does.

The Pre-Mortem, Not the Post-Mortem

In 2007, decision researcher Gary Klein built that finding into a simple team exercise he called the pre-mortem, the opposite of the post-mortem most businesses only run once something has already gone wrong. Instead of asking what could go wrong with this plan, you tell the room the plan already has gone wrong, and ask everyone to explain why. Run it as four steps before you approve anything.

  • 1. Pick the date — name the exact date this plan was meant to deliver on, not a vague point sometime next year
  • 2. Declare the failure in writing — before the meeting, send one line: imagine it is that date and this plan did not work
  • 3. Write reasons alone first — everyone writes their own list privately before anyone speaks, so the most senior voice in the room does not anchor everyone else's answer
  • 4. Give the top three reasons an owner and a fix — before you approve the plan, not after it is already underway

"He really got our vision from the beginning and has been a huge help in putting together a clearer plan and strategy for the next five years. Working with Kevin D'Ambros-Smith has given us the space to pause and reflect, on where we are now, where we want to be and how we get there."

— Gabby Kirk, Papier Hq

Why Owners Skip It Anyway

Most owners who have heard of the pre-mortem still skip it, for the same reason they skip most structured thinking under pressure: it requires someone in the room, often the owner, to be the one who says let's imagine this fails out loud, in front of a team they are trying to inspire. That is an uncomfortable thing to volunteer for without someone else holding the space for it. This is precisely the role a coach plays from outside the business, not writing the plan for you, but building the room where naming the real risk is the job, not a betrayal of morale. Owners who run this with a structured partner around them stop writing plans built on hope and start writing plans built on evidence they have already stress-tested.

Key Takeaways

  • Imagine the plan has already failed, not just that it could fail — it surfaces specific risks a hypothetical question never does
  • Name the date the plan was meant to deliver on before you ask anyone what went wrong
  • Have every person write their own list privately before the group discusses anything
  • Give the top three risks a named owner and a fix before you approve the plan, not after

If nobody in your last planning session was willing to say out loud what could kill it, that is the first thing Kevin helps you fix.

...and you become the owner whose plan has already survived its own worst day.