Friday, September 04, 2026

Your team's biggest time drain probably isn't a lack of hustle — it's meetings that never needed to happen. Here's the test for which ones survive.

Most owners blame a bad hire on a bad interview. The interview is almost never where it actually went wrong. A February 2026 survey of more than 950 small businesses across Australia and New Zealand, run by Seek with advisory firm Nature, found wrong hires now cost Australian SMEs an estimated 7.3 billion dollars a year collectively, with a single incorrect hire costing roughly 16,000 dollars once recruitment, training and the direct effect on the business are added up. If you want business systems that actually stop this, the fix starts weeks before anyone sits in a chair across from a candidate.

The Job Ad Was Already the Problem

In that same Seek and Nature research, the cost of a bad hire broke down as 55 percent recruitment and rehiring, 34 percent training and performance management, and 11 percent direct effect on the business. Almost none of that cost traces back to how the candidate performed in an interview. It traces back to a role that was never clearly defined before the ad went up, so the business hired a person rather than a measurable outcome.

The Who Method, in Plain English

Geoff Smart and Randy Street studied thousands of hiring decisions and built a structured method they called Who, often referred to as the A-Method, specifically because most hiring mistakes happen before the interview, not during it.

  • 1. Write the scorecard first — the specific outcomes this role must deliver in the first 12 months, not a list of duties
  • 2. Source wider than your inbox — actively find candidates rather than waiting to see who applies to the ad
  • 3. Ask the same structured questions of everyone — what did you actually do in your last role, not what would you do here
  • 4. Reference for specifics — ask every referee for one concrete example, not a general character reference

"What we achieved in the last 3 months working with Kevin would have taken 2 years. Kevin's assistance has been very inspirational to our staff. We have achieved changes and changes of thought patterns it could have taken 2 years in normal trading conditions."

— Chris, Global Culture

Why the Scorecard Gets Skipped

Writing a proper scorecard takes an hour of uninterrupted thinking, and most owners hire exactly when they have the least spare time to give it, which is precisely why the step gets skipped under pressure every single time. This is one of the clearest places a coach adds immediate, measurable value: not sitting in on the interview, but forcing the scorecard conversation to happen before the job ad is written, when it is still cheap to get right.

Key Takeaways

  • Wrong hires cost Australian SMEs an estimated 7.3 billion dollars a year collectively
  • Only 11 percent of that cost is the direct business impact; most of it is recruitment, rehiring, training and management time
  • Write the scorecard, the measurable outcomes the role must deliver, before you write the job ad
  • Ask every candidate and every referee for specific past examples, never a hypothetical or a general impression

If your last hiring decision started with a job ad instead of a scorecard, that gap is costing you more than the salary.

...and you become the owner who hires against a scorecard, not a hunch.