Friday, November 13, 2026
Most strategic plans don't fail because the strategy is wrong — they fail because they're too big to run. New data on 20,582 real plans shows where the cliff is, and how to fix it.
Last updated 16 November 2026. Published by Simple-Growth (Motherbase Limited). Market: North America survey data; the test applies to NZ and US owners alike.
If you swapped your logo onto your closest competitor's website and nothing read wrong, you don't have a marketing problem. You have a positioning problem, and most SME owners have one without realising it.
A 2026 study by Cashew ("Everyone Said That"), surveying 206 senior marketers across North America, found 65% admit to what the report calls differentiation anxiety: the nagging sense that their content could belong to any one of their competitors, with no clear idea how to fix it. If marketers running sophisticated brand budgets feel this, the odds are good your own marketing has the same problem, just with nobody watching for it.
Here's the uncomfortable test. Pull up your homepage headline, your elevator pitch, your why choose us page, and your last three social posts. Now mentally swap in your closest competitor's name. If every sentence still makes sense, your marketing was never really about you, it was about the category you're both competing in.
This happens because SME owners default to safe language under pressure: quality, trusted, experienced, we care about our customers. These words feel responsible. They also feel invisible, because every competitor reaching for the same reassurance is saying the exact same thing, in roughly the same order, hoping it lands differently for them. It rarely does. Buyers can't choose between two businesses that sound identical, so they default to the cheapest one, the opposite outcome most owners are trying to create.
This is the exercise I run with clients before we write a single word of new copy. It takes about twenty minutes and needs nothing but a notepad.
1. Collect five pieces of your current marketing. Homepage headline, elevator pitch, about us page, your last three LinkedIn posts, and one piece of sales collateral.
2. Run the swap. For each one, literally substitute a named competitor into the sentence. Does it still read true?
3. Mark every sentence that survives the swap. These are your sameness sentences. They cost you the sale every time a buyer can't tell you apart from the next quote.
4. Find the sentence that fails the swap. Somewhere in your business is a fact, a method, a story or a stance that genuinely could not be said by a competitor. That sentence is your real positioning, not the one that sounds most professional, the one that is most true only of you.
5. Rebuild from there. The sentence that fails the swap becomes your headline. Everything else gets rewritten to support it, not repeat it.
"Kevin D'Ambros-Smith was the first coach that helped us and he was so great. He understood the business straightaway, was able to identify some of the areas where we could grow it, and some of the things to park. I don't think the ROW branding would be nearly as strong without his input."
— Sarah McGuinness, Founder and CEO, Revolutionaries of Wellbeing (ROW)
That is one person's experience, not a promise of your result.
Most owners I work with aren't blind to this. They've felt the sameness in their own marketing for months. What stops them fixing it isn't insight, it's one of three things: fear that a sharper position will turn away business they can't afford to lose; no process that forces every new piece of marketing back through the test; or simply no outside eye checking the work before it goes live. Inside a business, sounds professional quietly replaces sounds like us, because nobody in the room is required to notice the difference.
This is where a second pair of eyes earns its keep, not to write cleverer copy, but to catch the sameness sentences before a client, a board or a competitor does.
Run the Swap Test on your homepage headline before 9am tomorrow. If it fails, don't rewrite it from scratch, find the one true, specific fact buried in your about us page and lead with that instead. Then ask one customer, in their own words, why they picked you over the obvious alternative; their answer is usually sharper copy than anything written in-house.
This is the exact discipline I spent years building inside global agencies, DDB, Ogilvy and Saatchi and Saatchi, on behalf of 60-plus global brands, before bringing the same process down to a scale an SME owner can run in an afternoon. Over 30 years and 200-plus businesses coached one-on-one later, positioning is still the cheapest fix available to most SME owners, and the one most skip because it feels soft compared to a new ad campaign or a sales push.
Source (North America data, opened 16 November 2026): Cashew, "Everyone Said That" 2026 marketer survey, via Retail Insider (North America, 206 senior marketers). Last updated 16 November 2026.
If your homepage headline fails the Swap Test, a session with Kevin will find the one line only your business can say, before you spend another dollar on marketing.
Monday, September 21, 2026
Time who talks in your next coaching session. If it's mostly your coach, you're getting a lecture — not the accountability that actually changes behaviour.
Monday, September 21, 2026
Chasing wholesale and DTC at once usually means neither gets funded properly. Here's the Channel Mix Audit to pick a primary channel and actually grow.
Monday, September 21, 2026
26% of small business owners plan to spend $0 on marketing this month — and it's capping their growth more than they realize. Here's the Marketing Floor framework to fix it.
Monday, September 21, 2026
Most strategic plans are built on what founders assume customers buy — not what they actually say. Here's the one-week audit that closes the gap.
Monday, September 21, 2026
Most SME marketing still targets a customer persona sketched out years ago. Here's how to find out who's actually buying — and fix the mismatch.
Monday, September 21, 2026
Most SME sales proposals are built to impress, not to close. Here's the one-page format that gets buyers to yes faster.
Monday, September 21, 2026
If Sunday afternoon has become the least relaxing part of your weekend, it's a design problem, not a discipline one. Here's the fix.
Monday, September 21, 2026
Most owners choose a coaching format by budget, not by stage. Here's the test that shows which format actually fits your business right now.
Monday, September 21, 2026
Private label deals look like free growth — until they quietly cost you margin, capacity, and control. Here's how to protect your brand before signing.
Monday, September 21, 2026
New global research says 68% of small business owners now choose stability over speed — and that's the smarter growth strategy. Here's the 3-step Depth Audit to grow without breaking what you've built.
Thursday, September 17, 2026
Most growth strategies don't fail because the market changed — they fail because nobody tested the assumptions underneath them. Here's the four-question audit that catches the weak spot before it costs you a year.
Thursday, September 17, 2026
Your website, socials, and sales team may all be telling a slightly different story. Consistent brands see up to 33% more revenue — here's the one-page Message Map that fixes the drift.
Thursday, September 17, 2026
Sales closes the deal, then delivery loses the customer within a quarter. The one-page Handover Brief that carries the promise, the anxiety, and the customer's real definition of success forward.
Thursday, September 17, 2026
Every interruption costs roughly 23 minutes of refocus time, not seconds. The Protected Block system that stops "always available" from quietly destroying your most productive hours.
Thursday, September 17, 2026
Coaching doesn't feel like steady progress — it dips hard around week five before the real structural change lands. Here's the 90-day curve nobody warns owners about, and why it matters.