Saturday, November 14, 2026

Only 30% of surveyed US owners beat 2025 profit expectations, down from 57% (Bluevine). The E-Myth shows SME owners why margin, not volume, is the real growth number.

Last updated 20 November 2026. Published by Simple-Growth (Motherbase Limited). Market: New Zealand and the United States. Survey figures are from US owners.

Ask yourself why your last five lost customers picked someone else. If you can't answer in one sentence, you're not alone. A Small Business Expo survey of 1,179 US owners, published April 2026, found 39.7% say competition in their industry is getting harder, not easier. You feel the squeeze even before the numbers catch up: a competitor matches your price within days, copies your offer within weeks, and the thing you once believed made you different quietly stops working. You're starting to sound like everyone else in your market, because you're all still fighting over the same customers in the same way.

Working Harder At The Same Game Isn't A Strategy

Most owners respond to rising competition by working harder at the same game: better service, faster turnaround, a sharper price. It feels like strategy. It's actually surrender, because it accepts the competitor's terms and tries to win on them. When everyone in your category is judged on the same handful of things, the business with the deepest pockets usually wins eventually, even if you win this quarter. The real cost isn't one lost deal. It's training your best customers to compare you on the one thing you can never permanently win.

Four Questions That Make You Different From Your Rivals

These questions come from Blue Ocean Strategy, a book by W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne. They studied fast-growing companies and found most weren't the best at competing. They had simply stopped competing for the same customers in the same way. Kim and Mauborgne call a crowded market, where every business chases the same buyers and prices keep falling, a "red ocean". A "blue ocean" is space you create yourself, by changing what customers compare you on. You don't need a new industry. You need four honest questions about your own offer.

  • Eliminate — what does your industry assume is essential that your best customers have never actually asked for?
  • Reduce — where are you over-investing to match competitors, on something that never decided a single sale?
  • Raise — what does every business in your category under-deliver, that your best customers genuinely care about?
  • Create — what could you offer that nobody in your category offers at all?

Kevin saw this with a plumbing business in Cambridge, New Zealand. Most trades compete on the same three things: price, speed and reliability. This team leaned into its own culture instead. Its tradespeople call themselves the Good Buggers (Kiwi slang for genuinely decent people), and that was how they worked long before it became their brand. Customers didn't just get a plumber. They got a team they actually wanted back in their house, and a rival couldn't copy that without becoming a completely different company. The point: customers stopped comparing them with the next plumber on price, because there was nothing like them to compare.

"I have grown my business 5x since working with Kevin. Everything Kevin told me to do was the complete opposite of what I had been doing. Working with Kevin has truly been a complete game changer."

Richard
Chem Suppliers

Why Owners Keep Competing On Price Anyway

Most owners can explain why standing out matters in under a minute. Almost none act on it, because cutting something out feels like leaving money on the table, and narrowing your offer feels riskier than matching the market. So you default to being a slightly better version of everyone else, which feels safest and is the slowest way to grow. This isn't for you if you've already tested a genuinely different offer against the businesses you actually lose to. For everyone else, find your difference before you spend another dollar on marketing that sounds like everyone else's.

An outside eye earns its keep here, because you're too close to your own business to see what makes it different. It looks obvious to you, so you assume it's obvious to everyone, and you stop saying it out loud. Someone outside the business can often spot it quickly.

Key Takeaways

  • Recognise that matching competitors harder is not a strategy, it's surrender on their terms.
  • Run the four questions (eliminate, reduce, raise, create) on your own offer this week, honestly.
  • Find the one thing your rivals don't offer, the way a Cambridge plumbing team did, by building it into how you work, not into a slogan.
  • Stop competing only on price, speed and reliability, the three things everyone already competes on.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Blue Ocean Strategy?

A framework from W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne showing that fast-growing companies usually succeed by creating space no one else is competing for, rather than by competing harder in a crowded market.

How does a small business find its own blue ocean?

By asking what to eliminate, reduce, raise and create in your offer, compared with what your whole category competes on, and being honest about which of those things your best customers never actually cared about.

Where should a busy owner start?

Pull your last five lost deals, write down who you actually lost to, and ask what you were competing on that a different kind of business wouldn't even try to match.

More practical guides for owners are in the Simple-Growth growth tips hub. Last updated 20 November 2026.

If you're still competing on the same three things as everyone else in your category, that's the first thing worth fixing before your next marketing dollar goes out the door.