Friday, November 06, 2026

Finding out how last month went three weeks too late isn't a discipline failure. It's an accountability gap, and one weekly email closes it.

Last updated 16 November 2026. Published by Simple-Growth (Motherbase Limited). Market: New Zealand.

This is a story about an owner who wants to make the right call on the big decision sitting in front of them — new market, new hire, new site, new partner — but who has only ever tested it against their own gut, alone, usually around 11pm. Nobody outside the business has heard the plan out loud. Nobody has been asked to find the holes in it before money and months get spent proving them. That isn't caution. It's a decision running on confidence instead of evidence, and confidence feels identical to certainty right up until the moment it isn't.

The Enemy Is Calling A Solo Decision "Leadership"

Owners are taught that making the hard call alone is what leadership looks like. So the big decision gets made, defended and — if it goes wrong — absorbed, all in private. Nobody is the villain here; it's the quiet rule that asking for a second opinion before you commit looks like weakness rather than rigour. That rule is what turns a six-month head start into a six-month mistake, because the flaw a stranger would have spotted in ten minutes gets discovered instead by the market or the bank balance, usually at the worst possible time.

Kill The Plan Before It Can Kill You

Psychologist Gary Klein built a simple fix for this called the pre-mortem: before you commit to a decision, you imagine it is twelve months from now and the thing has already failed. Then you work backwards and write down every reason why, out loud, with someone else in the room who isn't afraid to say the uncomfortable thing.

  • Name the decision in one sentence, specific enough that two people could disagree about it.
  • Run the failure exercise properly — twelve months on, it hasn't worked. List every real reason, not the polite ones.
  • Fix only what you control — the two or three causes you can actually act on before you commit; the rest is the cost of moving at all.

One of Kevin's clients, a New Zealand forensics specialist, wanted into the US market. The easy version of that story is a lone expert landing in America on conviction alone. The real version is more useful: rather than going in solo, the firm partnered with the leading American firm already established there — a decision pressure-tested against someone who already knew exactly where it could fail, before a single client call was made on US soil.

"Kevin's knowledge and intellect on all things business — no matter what industry it is — he just seems to find gems that you can focus on. I catch up with Kevin once a week and it is definitely the highlight of my week. He just sees different opportunities so clearly. I would not have considered the B2C market as an opportunity before working with Kevin and now it is a major focus for us. He has opened up so many new opportunities for us."

John Roberts
Co-owner & COO, Oragene

Why You Still Decide Alone Anyway

Asking for a second opinion feels like admitting you don't already know the answer, and for an owner who built the business on being the one who always knows, that's an uncomfortable trade. The irony is the opposite is true: the fastest-moving owners aren't the ones with no doubts, they're the ones who get the doubts dealt with before launch instead of after. This isn't for you if you already run every big call past a board, a mentor or a trusted outside voice — some owners genuinely do, and it shows in how calmly they talk about what's coming next.

For everyone else circling the same decision alone since before winter: find one person outside the day-to-day who will tell you the truth before you commit, not after you've already spent the money proving them right.

Key Takeaways

  • Run a pre-mortem before any decision big enough to keep you up at night — imagine it has already failed, then work backwards.
  • Name the decision in one specific sentence before you test it; a vague decision can't be pressure-tested properly.
  • Borrow someone else's terrain knowledge before you enter it yourself, the way Kevin's forensics client partnered rather than went alone into the US.
  • Fix only what you can actually control before launch — the goal is fewer avoidable mistakes, not a guarantee of none.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a pre-mortem?

A pre-mortem, developed by psychologist Gary Klein, is an exercise where you imagine a decision has already failed and work backwards to list every real reason why, before you commit — so you can fix what's fixable in advance instead of discovering it the hard way.

Isn't this just overthinking the decision?

It's the opposite. A pre-mortem takes less than an hour and usually shortens the time to a confident decision, because it replaces weeks of circling the same scenarios alone with a short, structured exercise that surfaces the real risks once, properly.

Who should be in the room for a pre-mortem?

Someone with no stake in you being right — a mentor, a coach, a trusted peer or an advisory board member — not a staff member who reports to you and has every incentive to agree.

If you've been circling the same big decision alone since before winter, that's the conversation worth having first.