Tuesday, November 17, 2026

On 5 October 2026 the Commerce Commission began court action over online 'best of' lists it says were not independent. Here are seven checks to run on any 'best business coach' list before you let it shape your shortlist.

Dana runs a 40-person HVAC firm. On Monday her leadership team agrees five priorities. By Friday two are done, and nobody can say who dropped the other three. (Dana is an illustrative composite, not a real client.)

Someone tells her to adopt EOS or Scaling Up. These are two brand-name systems for running a management team. Each is a set of routines: agreed goals, a named owner for each goal, and regular meetings that check progress. Both are set up with the help of a trained outsider.

The side-by-side comparison I found is written by EOS, so treat what follows as EOS's view of both. Then use the three questions below to decide whether either one is the fix you need.

What both do

EOS says it this way: "Both help leadership teams build alignment, accountability, and execution."

Where they differ, according to EOS

EOS (Entrepreneurial Operating System), created by Gino Wickman

  • How EOS describes itself: "Simple, disciplined, complete". That is EOS's own framing, not a test result.
  • Company size: EOS lists 10 to 250 employees as its range, and says it is often chosen by companies with 10 to 100.
  • Routine: one weekly 90-minute leadership meeting.
  • Set up by: a professional "EOS Implementer", meaning a trained outside facilitator.

Scaling Up (also called Rockefeller Habits), created by Verne Harnish

  • How EOS describes it: "Comprehensive, detailed, data-rich".
  • Company size: broader, "effective through larger companies".
  • Routine: a daily huddle plus weekly, monthly, quarterly and annual meetings.
  • Set up by: a "Scaling Up Certified Coach", meaning a trained outside coach.

At 40 staff, Dana fits either range, so company size alone will not decide it.

Source: EOS Worldwide, "EOS vs. Scaling Up", a US-focused page. EOS advises: "Pick one and commit to it fully." Because EOS wrote the page, the Scaling Up descriptions are EOS's words, not Scaling Up's. The page gives no prices, so this post quotes none: check Scaling Up's own materials, and ask both for their fees, before you decide.

Three questions to ask first

  • How many people sit in your leadership team? My rule of thumb, not a study: with three or four people who talk daily, a light routine is easier to keep going. With a larger group across several sites, more structure may pay for itself.
  • Will you hold the meetings every week of the year? Count the hours. One weekly meeting is a different promise from a daily huddle plus monthly, quarterly and annual reviews. In my experience, the system that fails is the one people drop within the first couple of months.
  • Is a meeting rhythm really your problem? If deadlines slip because the offer is unclear, sales are uneven or everything waits on you, a new rhythm will not fix that. If Dana's real gap is that nobody owns each priority, a simple weekly list with one name against each item may fix it before any system.

The question neither page answers

Neither system tells you which problem to fix first. I am Kevin D'Ambros-Smith, a business coach who has coached 200+ businesses one-on-one since 2017. With every owner I start by finding the one thing holding the business back (sales, pricing, the team or your own time) before recommending any tool. Some owners I work with do choose EOS or Scaling Up; many need a smaller fix first (my experience, not a study).

If you are not sure what to fix first

The Know Your Future masterclass helps you define what success looks like for your business and your life, then map the route to get there (US$497, self-paced, 30-day money-back guarantee).

If you would rather talk it through, you can arrange a short meeting with me through simple-growth.com to see whether we are a good fit. That meeting is to decide whether to work together, not to solve your problem on the call.

Kevin D'Ambros-Smith coaches ambitious small-business owners in the USA and New Zealand. This post compares tools for information only. Last updated 20 November 2026.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

EOS, Scaling Up, Vistage, ActionCOACH or Simple-Growth? A fair comparison with best-for and not-ideal-if for each option, a fit matrix and a nine-question quiz.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

What does a business coach cost in New Zealand? Published monthly and hourly ranges, cheaper options, how RBPN co-funding can help, and a checklist for judging value.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

New 2026 global research shows trust alone only earns a brand 48 percent acceptance into new territory - relevance takes it to 71 percent. Here is the two-question test that finds the real gap before you spend on expansion.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

The personal touch that built your reputation at ten staff quietly becomes the bottleneck that breaks it at thirty. Here is how to turn a habit into a system before it costs you.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Most owners check star ratings and warm adjectives before hiring a coach. Here is the three-detail test that tells you whether a review is evidence or decoration.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

The Christmas shutdown is about eleven weeks away. Here is the one-page-per-role handover document that decides whether you actually switch off this year.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

The biggest sales research study ever run found the best reps ask, they don't tell. Here is the SPIN method, and the four questions that come before any pitch.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

No ad budget doesn't mean no reach. Here is the Dream 100 method for finding the audiences that already trust your exact customer, and earning your way in.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Most SME growth plans are really just wishlists with a due date. Here is the two-question strategic choice cascade that turns good ideas into an actual strategy.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Burger King sold Whoppers for one cent, but only within 600 feet of a McDonald's. Here is the small-business version of that play, for under $5k.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Customers rank quality and service three times higher than price, yet a third of marketers admit they can't say what makes their brand different. Here's the three-step audit that fixes the real problem before you touch your price list.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Most growth plans start with finding new customers. The cheapest lever is usually already inside the transaction happening right now - here's the Checkout Audit that finds it.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Most owners call a coach only once something's broken. The data on mentored businesses says the real value compounds earliest - here's the Two Doors test for deciding when.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Owners feel busy all day and still don't move the business forward. The research says task-switching is the hidden cost - here's the Three-Block Day that gets the best hours back.

Sunday, October 04, 2026

Owners chase new leads every Q4 while a cheaper, warmer list of past customers sits untouched. Here's the four-step Win-Back Sequence and the real economics behind it.