Friday, September 04, 2026
The first ninety days of coaching are almost always productive. Here's why so many engagements quietly plateau around month six, and how to keep them accelerating.
There is a particular kind of business coach who makes every session feel good and changes almost nothing. They validate the plan, praise the effort, and leave you feeling better about a decision that was quietly wrong. If every session with your coach leaves you comfortable, that comfort is the symptom worth paying attention to, not the proof the relationship is working. Kim Scott's research into management and feedback, built from her years leading teams at Google and Apple, names exactly why comfortable coaching so rarely moves the numbers, and the fix she proposes has nothing to do with being harsher.
Scott's core finding, drawn from watching managers across hundreds of teams, is that the biggest mistake leaders make is being too nice, avoiding the direct, specific feedback a person actually needs because it feels kinder not to give it. The avoidance feels like kindness in the moment and functions as a quiet withholding of exactly the information someone needed to improve. The data on what happens when feedback does get delivered quickly and directly is striking: Gallup's research on fast feedback found that 84 percent of employees who received prompt, specific feedback reported being engaged in their work, with fast feedback linked to roughly four times the engagement and four times the performance improvement of delayed or vague feedback. The upside of directness is not a personality trait. It is measurable.
Scott's model plots every piece of feedback on two axes at once, and both have to be present for it to work.
1. Care personally - the challenge only lands as coaching, not criticism, when the person giving it has clearly invested in the other person's actual success, not just in being right.
2. Challenge directly - naming the specific thing that is not working, in plain language, close to when it happened, rather than softening it into something vague enough to feel safe to say.
3. Avoid the two failure modes either side of it - ruinous empathy, where care without challenge lets a real problem slide unaddressed, and obnoxious aggression, where challenge without care lands as an attack instead of help.
"Kevin has been a game changer for us. I had tried a couple of high-profile US entrepreneur programs but found these just talked about mindset, whereas Kevin gives practical advice to grow your business that you can implement immediately."
Brett Abeille
Most owners say they want a coach who will tell them the truth, and then quietly prefer the one who agrees with them, because disagreement is uncomfortable even when it is exactly what is needed. A coach who only validates is easy to keep working with and genuinely difficult to grow from. The owners who get the most out of coaching are usually the ones who went looking for someone willing to challenge a plan they were proud of, not someone to confirm it. That willingness to sit in the discomfort of direct feedback, long enough for it to actually change a decision, is the entire value of the relationship.
Kevin works personally with SME owners who want the direct, candid read on their business, not the comfortable one, because that is the version that actually moves the number, and you become the owner who hears what you need to hear.