Sunday, October 04, 2026

Some coaches build a business out of being needed forever. Here's the Graduation Test: three questions that reveal whether your coach is transferring real capability, or just keeping you on retainer.

A nationally representative Gallup survey of employees who had quit a job found 42 percent believed their manager or organisation could have prevented their leaving, largely because nobody had a real, regular conversation with them before they decided to go. Gallup's own research on the fix is specific: one meaningful weekly conversation with each person makes them four times as likely to be highly engaged. The same pattern plays out in the coach-client relationship, and it is the reason the coaching that worked brilliantly in your first month can quietly stop working by your twelfth, if the coach never changes how they show up.

The One-Style Coach

The enemy here is the coach, or the owner, who assumes one coaching style fits every stage of the relationship. A brand-new owner, uncertain and short on structure, needs direction: clear steps, close checking-in, a plan laid out for them. An experienced owner eighteen months in needs something closer to a sounding board who mostly gets out of the way. A coach who keeps directing a capable owner breeds resentment. A coach who hands a brand-new owner total autonomy too early leaves them drifting. Most coaching relationships that quietly go stale are not a bad match, they are a good match that never adjusted.

Situational Leadership, Applied to Coaching

Paul Hersey and Ken Blanchard's situational leadership model was built for managers, but it maps directly onto good coaching: the right style depends on the person's readiness, not on a fixed personality or process. Four stages, in plain terms.

  • 1. Directing — for a brand-new owner or a brand-new problem, where the coach sets the steps clearly and checks in often
  • 2. Coaching — for someone who understands the plan but still needs encouragement and explanation of the why behind it
  • 3. Supporting — for a capable owner who has the skill but needs confidence, a sounding board more than instruction
  • 4. Delegating — for an owner who has both the skill and the confidence, where the coach mostly asks sharp questions and steps back

This is why the cadence matters as much as the content: a weekly catch-up, held consistently, is what lets a coach notice which of the four stages you are actually in before the relationship drifts.

"Keeping me sane and focused during uncertain times."

— Rachel Williams, Icehouse Coaching Programme

Why Owners Rarely Ask for the Change

Owners almost never tell a coach the relationship has stopped fitting, because it does not feel like a complaint, it feels like quiet disengagement from sessions that used to feel essential. The responsibility sits with the coach to notice the shift and adjust first, which is exactly why a credentialed, experienced coach, rather than a fixed programme, is worth paying for past the first few months.

Key Takeaways

  • Expect your coaching style to change as you move from directing, to coaching, to supporting, to delegating
  • Treat a stale-feeling session as a sign the style has not kept up with you, not proof coaching has stopped working
  • Remember a regular, genuine weekly conversation makes people roughly four times more likely to stay engaged, per Gallup
  • Ask directly whether your coach has noticed which stage you are in now

If your coaching sessions feel the same as they did a year ago, that is worth a direct conversation, and you become the owner whose coaching keeps pace with how far you have come.