A customer searching for your kind of business is now almost as likely to ask an AI chatbot as to open Google. In the past year, 45% of US consumers used an AI tool to get a local business recommendation — up from just 6% the year before — and 31% went straight to ChatGPT for it, according to BrightLocal's 2026 Local Consumer Review Survey of over 1,000 US consumers. Separately, Pew Research's 2026 study of US adults found that searching for information is now the single most common reason people open an AI chatbot at all.

Most SME owners have noticed this shift exists. Very few have changed a single sentence on their website because of it. After over 30 years in brand and communications, from McDonald's media plans to nine businesses of my own, I can tell you the gap between noticing a shift and acting on it is exactly where the opportunity sits.

The obvious move, and the one most agencies will sell you first, is schema markup — the behind-the-scenes code that tells search engines what's on a page. It's worth having for other reasons, but as a lever for AI visibility specifically, the evidence doesn't support it. A 2026 Ahrefs study tracking close to 6,000 pages over eight months found that adding schema markup made no measurable difference to how often a page was cited in AI Overviews, Google's AI Mode, or ChatGPT — the differences were statistically indistinguishable from zero.

What actually gets an AI engine to quote you isn't the code behind your page. It's whether the words on it directly answer a real question, in one specific, speakable sentence. AI engines summarise what's genuinely useful to repeat — and polished, on-brand marketing copy is, ironically, one of the hardest things for a machine, or a human skimming in ten seconds, to lift and repeat.

"Kevin, you distilled business, marketing and sales strategy into powerful simple concepts and actions with real life stories of your start-up business and corporate life. You walk the talk with empathy and passion. Feedback has been off the charts. The energy in the room was palpable."

— Nikki, MahiTahi / The Colab

Here's the real obstacle: specific, plain-spoken answers feel unpolished to the person approving the copy. Owners are trained to want language that sounds impressive, not language a machine would find easy to repeat verbatim. The two instincts pull in opposite directions, and brand polish usually wins the argument in the room — which is exactly backwards for how buyers, human or AI, actually find you now.

This is where an outside, evidence-first view earns its keep: someone who'll tell you the schema markup your last agency sold you isn't the lever, and that the plainer, blunter version of your FAQ is the one that actually wins the next ten customers.

Go deeper: this guide is part of our hub on how a small business can use AI to grow. Read NZ small businesses and AI: where to start, and point AI at the link that is holding you back before you spend on tools.

If you don't know what your website would say if an AI chatbot summarised it to a customer right now, that's worth finding out before you spend another dollar on ads.